The Thunderbird Award is the most prestigious award of Wagion Lodge 6, given for outstanding leadership and service to the lodge. The Thunderbird Award is traditionally presented annually to one youth (under 21) and one adult at the Lodge Fellowship Banquet. Below is a list of all recipients of the Thunderbird Award :
- 1. K. T. Williamson* – 1957
- 2. Dwayne Welling* – 1958
- 3. Clarence Hayden*
- 4. Ernest Benford*
- 5. Art Seitz*
- 6. Clyde Shaw, Sr.*
- 7. Dennis Wolfe
- 8. Clarence Jackson*
- 9. Ronald Crawford – 1959
- 10. George Mooney II*
- 11. Paul Eckman* – 1960
- 12. Ed Wigger
- 13. Tony Quaranto*
- 14. Jerry Sutherland – 1961
- 15. Bob Burkhardt*
- 16. Theo Fullerton – 1962
- 17. Fred Rankin*
- 18. Paul Burd* – 1963
- 19. Jim Shotts
- 20. Don McCombs – 1964
- 21. Harry Baker*
- 22. Jack Cogley – 1965
- 23. Bob Gault*
- 24. G. Edward Lewis* – 1966
- 25. Duane Silvis
- 26. Robert Maher – 1967
- 27. John S. Maykuth, Sr.*
- 28. Adrian Horvath – 1968
- 29. Chuck Ferguson
- 30. Bill Baughman – 1969
- 31. Bill Shaffer*
- 32. Karl Mosso – 1970
- 33. Clinton E. Rohrbacher, Sr.*
- 34. Frederick Curcio, Jr. * – 1971
- 35. Jack Ivory
- 36. Dave Delisi – 1972
- 37. Bob Newquist*
- 38. Jim Harper – 1973
- 39. Bill Carmichael*
- 40. Vincent Joshnson – 1974
- 41. Benjamin Robinson*
- 42. Robert Pierattini – 1975
- 43. Ray Flock*
- 44. Fred Frank – 1976
- 45. Charles Wolenter*
- 46. C. Mitchell Clausner, Jr. * – 1977
- 47. Jack Gillis*
- 48. Thomas Kapelewski – 1978
- 49. Edison Rice*
- 50. Jerry Frank – 1979
- 51. Mike Blasko
- 52. Tom Vater – 1980
- 53. Ben Piper
- 54. Dave Hostoffer – 1981
- 55. Grant Keefer*
- 56. Robert D. Koncerak, Jr – 1982
- 57. Andrew Shimko
- 58. Phil Klocek – 1983
- 59. Jay Weitzel
- 60. Dave Pfeifer – 1984
- 61. Robert E. Miller*
- 62. Dave Murphy – 1985
- 63. Mike Lucotch
- 64. Bill Bolosky – 1986
- 65. Ross Hackel
- 66. Dave Kadylak – 1987
- 67. Sam Scruggs*
- 68. Larry Malego – 1988
- 69. Tony Duda*
- 70. Mark Henry – 1989
- 71. Herb Harris
- 72. George Parker – 1990
- 73. Charlie Dunn
- 74. Ken Koncerak – 1991
- 75. Dave Byers*
- 76. Robert S. Hepler Jr. – 1992
- 77. Charles Galvin
- 78. Rel Orzehowski, Jr. – 1993
- 79. Richard M. Ashford
- 80. Matt Ayres – 1994
- 81. Kevin Beamer
- 82. Adam Mates – 1995
- 83. Brad Smalley
- 84. Jim Bittner, Jr. – 1996
- 85. Mark Kardos
- 86. Regis Dunn – 1997
- 87. Glenn Gates
- 88. Jeremy Steck – 1998
- 89. H. Richard Browning
- 90. Christopher Lehman – 1999
- 91. Fr. George E. Saletrik
- 93. John A. “Jack” Waite
- 94. John Krempecki – 2001
- 95. William Hoegel
- 96. Jason Chuma – 2002
- 97. William Carney
- 98. Nathaniel Shaffer – 2003
- 99. Don Harris*
- 100. William E. “Wes” Scarlett – 2004
- 101. Jerry Clark
- 102. Kenneth J. Hager – 2005
- 103. William Loeffler
- 104. Darek J. Kelsey – 2006
- 105. Daniel J. Wright
- 106. Allen J. Martello, Jr. – 2007
- 107. Dennis Kinzel
- 108. Thomas P. Price – 2008
- 109. J. Richard Hager*
- 110. David Scarlett – 2009
- 111. Donald Bixby
- 112. Adam Kostik – 2010
- 113. Clyde Shaw, Jr.
- 114. Kenneth E. Bartlett Jr. – 2011
- 115. James Gettins
- 116. Eric W. Bush – 2012
- 117. Mary Pishko
- 118. Elliot Diamond – 2013
- 119. Tom Irwin
- 120. Robbie Lavelle – 2014
- 121. Jim Crace
- 122. Evan Bair – 2015
- 123. Martin Barbie
- 124. Caleb Maddas – 2016
- 125. William Bush
- 126. Andrew Colebank – 2017
- 127. Clark D. Guy
- 128. Michael Conroy – 2018
- 129. Robert “Bobby” Frye
- 130. Isaac Melvin – 2019
- 131. Michael Jackson*
- 132. Braden Coffman – 2020
- 133. Daniel Ferguson
- 134. Zachary Lacombe – 2021
- 135. Jeffrey Lydic
- 136. Jayden Provance – 2022
- 137. Mike Stafford
- 138. Logan Depta – 2023
- 139. James Jackson Jr.
- 140. Daniel Sosko – 2024
- 141. Daniel Laco
* Deceased